This review contains affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no cost to you. We only recommend gear that fits our plastic-free standard.

A $479.99 drip coffee maker is having a moment. The Simply Good Coffee Plastic-Free Brewer is marketed as the only automatic drip machine with a fully plastic-free brew path, it has been covered by CNET, Forbes, Tom’s Guide, and the Washington Post, and it sells out into waitlists. In late 2025 it got another surge of attention when a large maker audience was pointed straight at it. Since plastic-free brewing is the entire reason this site exists, we owe you a straight answer: does the claim hold up, and do the people who actually own one still like it?

One thing before we start. We have not run this machine in our own kitchen yet. What follows is a specs-and-claims analysis paired with owner-report research: we went through the manufacturer’s published materials list, spec sheet, manual, and parts catalog, then read through owner reviews on Reddit and long-term write-ups from reviewers who have used the machine daily for months, the same way we would vet any machine before recommending it. When we get hands-on time with one, we will update this review with our own testing.

Check current price and availability: Simply Good Coffee Plastic-Free Brewer on Amazon

What the Simply Good Coffee Brewer Is

The Plastic-Free Brewer is an 8-cup (40 oz) automatic drip machine that behaves like a standard one-button brewer: fill the borosilicate glass reservoir, add a #4 cone filter and grounds, press the button. A stainless steel boiler holds the water in the 195 to 205°F range, a bloom cycle pre-wets the grounds pour-over style, and a full pot takes about 6 minutes. It is tested to the Specialty Coffee Association’s Golden Cup standard, the same certification the Moccamaster carries. Note that the Plastic-Free model is the premium tier of the lineup; Simply Good also sells cheaper Glass (around $159) and Thermal (around $219) versions that share the brew head but use plastic parts. This review is about the plastic-free model specifically.

The Design Lineage: A Moccamaster, Rethought in Glass and Steel

Look at this machine next to a Technivorm and the family resemblance is unmistakable: the upright tower silhouette, the reservoir-beside-brewer layout, the rapid boiler feeding a showerhead over a cone basket. That is not a criticism. The Moccamaster template has been the benchmark for serious drip brewing for 50 years, and Simply Good has clearly studied it, then re-engineered the one thing the benchmark never fixed: every plastic contact point in the water path. Tom’s Guide, which has tested it hands-on, titled its review “a fantastic Moccamaster alternative.” The pitch, in one line: the drip formula you already trust, with glass, steel, and silicone where the plastic used to be.

The Brew Path, Piece by Piece

Simply Good publishes a component-level materials list, which is more transparency than almost any coffee maker brand offers. Per the manufacturer, every surface that touches water or coffee is one of three materials:

• 304 stainless steel: boiler, internal plumbing, shower arm and showerhead, filter basket and basket lid, reservoir floor cover, carafe top
• Borosilicate glass: water reservoir, boiler tube, carafe
• Medical-grade silicone: reservoir cover, carafe lid seal, connectors, drip stop

Silicone deserves a note. It is made from silica, not petroleum, which is why it passes our definition of plastic free, the same standard we apply to our own products. No aluminum in the path either, which matters to some readers.

What Is Verified, and What Is Marketing

The core claim looks solid on paper: a fully plastic-free hot water path in a home automatic drip machine, out of the box, which no mainstream competitor offers. The company also publishes independent testing reports, and replacement parts for every wetted component are sold separately, a good sign for longevity.

Worth addressing head-on: Tom’s Guide calls the machine “low plastic” rather than plastic free, pointing to the silicone water lines and some plastic exterior parts. Both observations are accurate, and neither changes our read. Silicone is not a petroleum-based plastic, which is the standard we hold our own products to, and exterior housing parts never touch your water. If your personal bar is zero synthetic materials anywhere on the machine, no electric brewer clears it.

Now the honest flags. The biggest one is the warranty, which has confused a lot of shoppers. The brewer carries a 2-year warranty as standard. The widely advertised 5-year warranty is not automatic: it requires enrolling in Simply Good’s Coffee Quality Assurance Program, a paid coffee subscription. That distinction is easy to miss on the marketing pages, and at least one owner flagged the subscription requirement as an unwelcome surprise, so factor it in rather than assuming five years of free coverage. There has also been some inconsistency in how the company’s own spec pages describe the filter basket (stainless steel in the spec table, glass in a feature blurb), so confirm the exact configuration at checkout. None of this undermines the materials story, and a 30-day return window is your safety net.

What Owners Actually Report

Because we have not brewed with one ourselves, we leaned on people who have. Here is the honest pattern from owner reviews on Reddit (r/PlasticFreeLiving, r/Costco, r/BuyItForLife and others) and from long-term reviewers who have run the machine daily for months. The overall sentiment is positive, with a handful of consistent caveats worth knowing before you spend nearly $480.

What owners praise:

• The cup. Owners on Reddit consistently describe a clean, balanced brew, and several who roast their own beans say it does the coffee justice. One long-term reviewer who has run hundreds of batches reports a rich, smooth result comparable to a French press with the cleaner texture of a pour-over.
• Batch convenience. Multiple owners call it a genuine upgrade for making coffee for more than one person, and one reviewer regularly brews large morning pots with good results.
• The bloom button and temperature consistency. Owners like that it pre-wets the grounds and holds the water in the correct range without a fussy control panel.
• Durability so far. One reviewer reported roughly 500 brew cycles with no parts replaced, though owners note the brand is still young and long-term reliability is unproven.
• The flow-control lever. Reviewers highlight the mechanical basket lever as a legitimately useful feature for pausing the brew or experimenting with extraction, something the Moccamaster does not offer.

Common complaints:

• Fit and finish on some units. This is the recurring gripe among plastic-free owners specifically. Reports on Reddit include a bent mixer arm on the carafe lid, a body that leans slightly toward the carafe, and a crooked showerhead intake. More than one owner says the glass carafe feels thin, and one said the machine did not feel like a $480 product and was considering a return.
• The spill trap. Nearly every owner and reviewer mentions the same thing: if you leave the filter-basket lever in the closed position and walk away, the basket overflows onto the counter. It is user error, but it is a mistake almost everyone makes once. Leave it open unless you are deliberately steeping.
• A weak basket magnet. One long-term reviewer notes the magnet holding the filter basket in place is not very strong, so the basket can knock loose if you are not deliberate about seating it.
• Bloom on big batches. The bloom feature works best on smaller doses (around 30 grams or less); on large pots the showerhead does not saturate all the grounds evenly.
• Handle ergonomics. One owner felt the carafe handle is shaped backwards, flat where your fingers wrap and rounded where your thumb presses.

The through-line: owners are happy with the coffee and the plastic-free design, but a few received units with fit-and-finish flaws, and no one should expect flawless luxury build at this price. The taste and materials are the reasons to buy; the build-quality lottery and the warranty fine print are the reasons to keep your receipt and your 30-day window in mind.

How It Compares to the BUNN VP17-1 and the Moccamaster

Until now, our answer for plastic-free drip was the BUNN VP17-1, a commercial brewer that becomes fully plastic free once you swap its stock funnel for BUNN’s stainless basket, a trick we broke down in our BUNN VP17-1 review. The BUNN is the volume champion, built for diners, but it is a commercial appliance and needs that funnel swap to earn the plastic-free title. The Simply Good gets there out of the box in a home-sized, one-button format.

Against the Technivorm Moccamaster, the machine it so clearly echoes, the trade is straightforward. The Moccamaster brings five decades of proven reliability and a no-enrollment 5-year warranty; as we detail on that page, hot water there passes a BPA-free plastic outlet arm and brew basket on the way down. The Simply Good removes those contact points entirely, adds a flow-control lever and a bloom button the Moccamaster lacks, and brews into the same temperature window. But it costs more: $479.99 list against roughly $360 for current Moccamasters, and its comparable 5-year coverage is tied to a paid subscription. You are not paying less for the familiar formula, you are paying a premium for the plastic-free version of it. Whether that premium is worth it is exactly the question this category has never let you ask before.

Who It Is For at $480

• Drip-coffee households that want zero plastic in the hot path without a commercial machine or a funnel swap
• Moccamaster shoppers who walked away over the plastic brew basket
• Anyone consolidating from pour-over back to a one-button morning, without giving up the materials standard

If you brew one or two cups rather than pots, a glass Chemex or ceramic dripper still gets you plastic-free for a fraction of the money.

Ready to buy? Check the latest price here: Simply Good Coffee Plastic-Free Brewer on Amazon

Where This Fits at Plastic Free Brew

A quick note on why we are happy to point you toward a machine we do not make. The Simply Good brewer is a drip machine, so it is complementary to what we do, not competition. We curate plastic-free gear across the whole coffee routine, and different people want different things. If you want a full pot from a one-button automatic drip brewer with zero plastic in the water path, this is the strongest option we have found. If you brew single servings and want that same standard, our own PaperPods give you compostable, plastic-free pods instead. And if you need commercial volume, the BUNN VP17-1 is still on the table. We would rather send you to the right plastic-free tool for your routine than pretend one machine fits everyone.

Our Verdict, For Now

On the published specs and the owner reports we have read, the Simply Good Coffee Plastic-Free Brewer is the machine this category has been missing: the first home automatic drip brewer with a documented, fully plastic-free brew path, built on the most proven design template in drip coffee. The materials transparency is best in class, the SCA certification says the coffee side is serious, and owners broadly back that up on taste. We are holding our final rating until we brew with one ourselves, given the fit-and-finish reports on some units and the warranty fine print, but on paper and in owners’ hands this is the most complete answer yet to the question our readers ask most. If you buy one, keep your 30-day return window in mind and inspect the unit on arrival.

See current pricing and availability: Simply Good Coffee Plastic-Free Brewer on Amazon